Some think second homes are essentially becoming an extravagance and that as investment vehicles, they may not be attractive. There are two reasons for this;
1. The effect tough times have on second homes
There is some difference of opinion surrounding what effect a downward trend in the housing market might have on second homes. Some experts feel that more and more people, if faced with the choice of being able to keep only one of their homes during financial difficulties, will actually choose to keep the second home. Why? Because second homes are where the “heart is.” In other words, the second home is becoming the favorite.
Historically, the exact opposite has happened and people have let go of their second home as though it was a disposable and unaffordable asset that needed to be sold off. If the market gets much worse, many believe these second homes will be sold.
Some analysts subscribe to the traditional definition of a second home - a place where relatively affluent people stay in order to enjoy well liked locations for some period of the year. However, second homes may not fit as easily into these traditional categories as they once did. People live in second homes because they like variety, freedom, or convenience. This might be why they would hang on to them if given the choice.
2. The real costs of owning a second home
If you add up all the costs associated with second home ownership, you could easily come to the conclusion that you can actually end up losing some money. This is why many believe that second homes need to be viewed more as luxury items than anything else.
However, this argument does not take into consideration all the reasons that a second home was purchased in the first place. Most people buy vacation homes because they take regular vacations. The costs of housing a family in a comparable hotel can be exorbitant.
In addition, many second home owners rent out their homes when they are not using them, bringing in income that can support the mortgage payments. Finally, second homes are an investment for the future, a way of passing on assets to the children. The idea of loss or gain on a second home becomes relevant only when you are in it for the short term. To most owners, long term second home ownership is not as much a luxury as it is a lifestyle.